The Nightmare is a large fiend with AC 13, 68 hit points (8d10 + 24) and a challenge rating of 3 (700 XP). On its turn it deals about 23.5 damage if every attack hits, or 15.1 on average against AC 15. For four level-3 characters, 0 make a low, 1 a moderate and 2 a high-difficulty encounter (2024 rules).
ChallengeCR 3700 XP · PB +2
Armor Class13+7 hits 75%
Hit points688d10 + 24
Damage per round23.515.1 vs AC 15
Nightmare statistics (2024 rules)
STR18+4
DEX15+2
CON16+3
INT10+0
WIS13+1
CHA15+2
Speed
60 ft., fly 90 ft.
Damage immunities
fire
Senses
passive perception 11
Languages
Understands Abyssal, Common, and Infernal but can’t speak
Traits
Confer Fire Resistance, Illumination
Attacks and actions
Action
To hit / save
Damage
Average
Expected vs AC 15
Hooves
+6
2d8+4 bludgeoning + 3d6 fire
23.5
15.1
Ethereal Stride
—
—
—
—
Fighting a nightmare
Its damage per round
Your AC
Expected damage
12
18.6
14
16.3
16
13.9
18
11.6
20
9.2
Your chance to hit it (AC 13)
Attack bonus
Hit
With advantage
+3
55%
80%
+5
65%
88%
+7
75%
94%
+9
85%
98%
+11
95%
100%
Rounds to defeat it
Party damage per round
Rounds
10
7
20
4
35
2
60
2
100
1
Expected damage counts misses, and doubles the dice on a 20. Recharge and save-based actions aren’t included in the per-round numbers. Plan a full fight in the encounter difficulty calculator.
How many nightmares for a party of four
The most nightmares (700 XP each) that fit each difficulty for four characters. 2024 rules use XP budgets; the 2014 rules multiply the XP of groups of monsters.
The nightmare has an Armor Class of 13 and 68 hit points (8d10 + 24) in the 2024 rules.
How much damage does a nightmare do?
Each turn it makes 1 Hooves attack (+6 to hit, 23.5 damage), 23.5 damage if all of them hit and about 15.1 on average against AC 15.
How many nightmares for a party of 4?
For four level-3 characters: 0 for a low-difficulty, 1 for a moderate and 2 for a high-difficulty encounter with the 2024 rules. The table on this page covers every level from 1 to 20.
How hard is it to hit a nightmare?
Against AC 13, an attack with +5 hits 65% of the time, +7 hits 75% and +9 hits 85%.
Statistics from the System Reference Document 5.1 and 5.2 by Wizards of the Coast LLC, licensed under CC-BY-4.0 (attribution). Damage, hit odds and encounter sizes are our own calculations.