Character Creation
Rolling vs Taking the Average for Hit Points
Why the fixed hit point value beats rolling on average, how much the gamble can cost or win you over a campaign, and how Constitution and feats add up.
Every time a character gains a level, the player chooses: roll the class’s hit die for new hit points, or take a fixed number. It feels like a choice between safety and excitement. The maths says it is mostly a choice between a small, certain advantage and a gamble that usually loses. Here are the numbers.
How hit points are gained
- At level 1 you get the maximum of your hit die plus your Constitution modifier: 12 + Con for a barbarian, 6 + Con for a wizard.
- At every level after that you either roll your hit die or take the fixed value, then add your Constitution modifier.
The rules are the same in the 2014 and 2024 editions, and so are the fixed values.
| Hit die | Classes | Fixed value | Average roll | Chance to roll higher | Chance to roll lower |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| d6 | Sorcerer, Wizard | 4 | 3.5 | 33% | 50% |
| d8 | Bard, Cleric, Druid, Monk, Rogue, Warlock | 5 | 4.5 | 37.5% | 50% |
| d10 | Fighter, Paladin, Ranger | 6 | 5.5 | 40% | 50% |
| d12 | Barbarian | 7 | 6.5 | 42% | 50% |
The fixed value is always half a point higher than the average roll. That is the whole argument in one line: on average, taking the fixed value wins.
What that means over a campaign
Half a point a level doesn’t sound like much. Over 19 level-ups (levels 2 to 20) it adds up to 9.5 hit points on average, but the bigger story is the spread. Working out every possible combination of rolls:
| Class | Fixed total (19 levels) | Average if rolled | Chance rolling ends up ahead |
|---|---|---|---|
| Wizard (d6) | 76 | 66.5 | 11% |
| Cleric (d8) | 95 | 85.5 | 19% |
| Fighter (d10) | 114 | 104.5 | 24% |
| Barbarian (d12) | 133 | 123.5 | 28% |
(Constitution is left out because it is the same either way.) A wizard who rolls every level has only about a 1-in-9 chance of finishing with as many hit points as one who took the fixed value, and a 50% chance of finishing ten or more behind. Bigger dice gamble better because there are more high faces, but even the barbarian loses the bet nearly three times in four.
When a bad roll really hurts
The danger of rolling isn’t the average, it is the early levels. A 2nd-level wizard who rolls a 1 has 6 + 1 = 7 hit points plus Constitution, against 6 + 4 = 10 with the fixed value. That is a third less, at the point in the game where a single goblin arrow can drop a character. For d6 and d8 classes, one or two bad rolls early can make a character noticeably more fragile for the whole campaign.
Constitution matters more than the roll
Your Constitution modifier is added at every level, including level 1. When it goes up, your hit point maximum goes up by 1 for every level you have, retroactively. Raising Constitution from 14 to 16 at level 8 is worth 8 hit points at once and 20 by level 20, more than twice what you gain by choosing fixed values over rolling.
Other sources stack on top:
- Tough feat: +2 hit points per level, also retroactive. At level 10 that is 20 extra hit points.
- Dwarves: +1 hit point per level from their species trait (hill dwarves in the 2014 rules, all dwarves in 2024).
- Some subclasses add hit points per level, such as the Draconic sorcerer.
Worked example
A fighter with 14 Constitution (+2) at level 5, taking fixed values:
- Level 1: 10 + 2 = 12
- Levels 2–5: 4 × (6 + 2) = 32
- Total: 44 hit points
With the Tough feat it would be 54; with 16 Constitution instead, 49. The D&D HP calculator does this for any class, level and multiclass combination, and can show both the fixed and the rolled results.
Table rules that make rolling fairer
Rolling is fun, and many groups enjoy the drama. If your table likes to roll, these house rules keep it exciting without punishing bad luck:
- Roll, but take the fixed value if it is higher. Rolling can only help. This pushes average hit points up, so encounters may need a nudge.
- Reroll 1s until you get something else. Removes the worst outcome and brings the average roll level with the fixed value.
- Roll in front of the group. Keeps everyone honest and makes level-up a shared moment.
Whatever your table chooses, choose it as a group so nobody feels the dice treated them unfairly.