Dice & Probability

Advantage and Disadvantage: The Real Math

Exactly how much advantage and disadvantage change your odds, why “about +5” is only true sometimes, and what it means for crits, saves and Elven Accuracy.

Advantage is the simplest rule in fifth edition: roll two d20s and keep the higher. Disadvantage keeps the lower. People often say advantage is “worth about +5”, but that is only true in one situation. This guide shows the exact numbers, explains when advantage matters most and least, and covers critical hits, saving throws and Elven Accuracy.

The exact formula

If p is your chance of success on one d20 roll, then:

With advantage: 1 − (1 − p)² · With disadvantage: p²

You fail with advantage only if both dice fail, and succeed with disadvantage only if both dice succeed. Everything else in this guide follows from those two lines.

Advantage and disadvantage by target number

Need on d20NormalAdvantageDisadvantageAdvantage is like
2+95%99.8%90.3%+1
4+85%97.8%72.3%+2.6
6+75%93.8%56.3%+3.8
8+65%87.8%42.3%+4.6
10+55%79.8%30.3%+5
11+50%75%25%+5
12+45%69.8%20.3%+5
14+35%57.8%12.3%+4.6
16+25%43.8%6.3%+3.8
18+15%27.8%2.3%+2.6
20+5%9.8%0.3%+1

The last column converts the gain into an equivalent flat bonus. It peaks at +5 when you need a 10 or 11, a coin flip, and shrinks towards the edges: if you need a 2 or a 20, advantage is worth less than +1. That is the real answer to “how much is advantage worth?”: a lot when the roll is uncertain, very little when it is almost certain either way.

Average rolls

A single d20 averages 10.5. With advantage the average result is about 13.8, and with disadvantage about 7.2. That gap of 3.3 either way is a useful rule of thumb for checks and initiative, where you compare a total with someone else’s rather than with a fixed target.

Critical hits

A natural 20 comes up on 5% of single rolls. With advantage you get at least one 20 on 9.75% of attacks; with disadvantage only on 0.25%. Characters who get big bonuses on a critical hit, such as rogues with Sneak Attack and paladins who smite, nearly double their crit chance with advantage. Features that crit on 19–20 make it even better: 10% per die, or 19% with advantage.

Three dice: Elven Accuracy and similar features

Some features let you roll a third die when you have advantage, such as the Elven Accuracy feat. The formula extends naturally: you fail only if all three dice fail.

With three dice: 1 − (1 − p)³

For a coin-flip attack (needing 11), that is 87.5% compared with 75% with normal advantage, and the crit chance rises to 14.3%.

When advantage and disadvantage meet

If you have both advantage and disadvantage on a roll, they cancel out and you roll one die, no matter how many sources of each you have. Three reasons for advantage and one reason for disadvantage still means one die. This is deliberate: it stops players stacking modifiers. It also means one source of disadvantage, such as being blinded or attacking at long range, can wipe out all your careful setup.

Saving throws

The same maths applies to saving throws. A monster with Magic Resistance has advantage on saves against spells, which changes how often your spells land:

  • Against a creature that would fail your save 50% of the time, Magic Resistance cuts that to 25%.
  • Against one that would fail 70% of the time, it drops to 49%.

Against those creatures, spells with an attack roll or no saving throw become more attractive. The spell save DC calculator shows both cases side by side.

Advantage or a flat bonus?

Should you take a feature that grants advantage, or one that adds +2? Use the formula above: advantage is worth more than a flat +2 whenever you need anything from 4 to 18 on the die, which covers most real rolls. Only when you already succeed on a 2 or 3, or need a 19 or 20, does the +2 come out ahead, and even then advantage still nearly doubles your crits. And because of the cancelling rule, advantage can vanish when the enemy imposes disadvantage, while a flat bonus never does.

To see the exact odds for any roll, including dice pools and target numbers, use the dice probability calculator, and to see what advantage does to your damage, the DPR calculator.

Sources: System Reference Document 5.1 and 5.2 (CC-BY-4.0) and the fifth edition core rules. Worked examples are our own. First published 7 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us and we will correct it. Read how we write and check our guides in our editorial policy.