The Will-o’-Wisp is a tiny undead with AC 19, 27 hit points (11d4) and a challenge rating of 2 (450 XP). On its turn it deals about 11 damage if every attack hits, or 6 on average against AC 15. For four level-2 characters, 0 make a low, 1 a moderate and 1 a high-difficulty encounter (2024 rules).
Expected damage counts misses, and doubles the dice on a 20. Recharge and save-based actions aren’t included in the per-round numbers. Plan a full fight in the encounter difficulty calculator.
How many will-o’-wisps for a party of four
The most will-o’-wisps (450 XP each) that fit each difficulty for four characters. 2024 rules use XP budgets; the 2014 rules multiply the XP of groups of monsters.
The will-o’-wisp has an Armor Class of 19 and 27 hit points (11d4) in the 2024 rules; in the 2014 rules it has AC 19 and 22 HP.
How much damage does a will-o’-wisp do?
Each turn it makes 1 Shock attack (+4 to hit, 11 damage), 11 damage if all of them hit and about 6 on average against AC 15.
How many will-o’-wisps for a party of 4?
For four level-2 characters: 0 for a low-difficulty, 1 for a moderate and 1 for a high-difficulty encounter with the 2024 rules. The table on this page covers every level from 1 to 20.
How hard is it to hit a will-o’-wisp?
Against AC 19, an attack with +5 hits 35% of the time, +7 hits 45% and +9 hits 55%.
Statistics from the System Reference Document 5.1 and 5.2 by Wizards of the Coast LLC, licensed under CC-BY-4.0 (attribution). Damage, hit odds and encounter sizes are our own calculations.