Best 4th-level damage spells

Ranked by expected damage: the average after misses or saving throws, cast by a character of the lowest level that can use this slot against a typical target of that level. Area spells hit several creatures, so they are worth more than the number for one target suggests.

#SpellDamage or healingAverageExpectedHit or saveRules
1Phantasmal Killer C4d10 psychic 2217.1Wisdom save, half damage on a success2014 & 2024
2Wall of Fire C5d8 fire 22.517.4Dexterity save, half damage on a success2014 & 2024
3Ice Storm2d10 bludgeoning + 4d6 cold 2519.4Dexterity save, half damage on a success2014 & 2024
4Vitriolic Sphere10d4 acid + 5d4 acid 37.526.3Dexterity save, half damage on a success2024
5Blight8d8 necrotic 3627.9Constitution save, half damage on a success2014 & 2024

How we compare spells

Average is the mean of the damage dice for one target, with every ray or dart hitting. Expected accounts for the dice you actually roll: spell attacks can miss (a 1 always misses, a 20 doubles the dice), and saving throws halve or cancel the damage. We use a caster of the lowest level that can cast the spell, with a +3, +4 or +5 spellcasting modifier as the levels go up, against a typical Armor Class and saving throw for that level. Healing spells are listed after damage spells and their numbers don’t include your modifier.

Try your own numbers in the DPR calculator, or see the odds of any damage roll on the dice odds pages.