Best 2nd-level damage spells

Ranked by expected damage: the average after misses or saving throws, cast by a character of the lowest level that can use this slot against a typical target of that level. Area spells hit several creatures, so they are worth more than the number for one target suggests.

#SpellDamage or healingAverageExpectedHit or saveRules
1Spiritual Weapon C1d8 force 4.53.2Melee spell attack2014 & 2024
2Flaming Sphere C2d6 fire 75.3Dexterity save, half damage on a success2014 & 2024
3Flame Blade C3d6 fire 10.57.4Melee spell attack2014
4Dragon's Breath C3d6 chosen 10.57.9Dexterity save, half damage on a success2024
5Moonbeam C2d10 radiant 118.3Constitution save, half damage on a success2014 & 2024
6Heat Metal C2d8 fire 99Hits automatically2014 & 2024
7Mind Spike C3d8 psychic 13.510.1Wisdom save, half damage on a success2024
8Shatter3d8 thunder 13.510.1Constitution save, half damage on a success2014 & 2024
9Acid Arrow4d4 acid + 2d4 acid 1512.3Ranged spell attack2014 & 2024
10Scorching Ray3 × 2d6 fire 2114.7Ranged spell attack2014 & 2024
11Prayer of Healing2d8 9—Healing2014

How we compare spells

Average is the mean of the damage dice for one target, with every ray or dart hitting. Expected accounts for the dice you actually roll: spell attacks can miss (a 1 always misses, a 20 doubles the dice), and saving throws halve or cancel the damage. We use a caster of the lowest level that can cast the spell, with a +3, +4 or +5 spellcasting modifier as the levels go up, against a typical Armor Class and saving throw for that level. Healing spells are listed after damage spells and their numbers don’t include your modifier.

Try your own numbers in the DPR calculator, or see the odds of any damage roll on the dice odds pages.