Combat Math

Great Weapon Master and Sharpshooter: When Is −5/+10 Worth It?

A simple rule for when to take the −5 to hit for +10 damage under the 2014 rules, how advantage changes it, and what the 2024 versions of the feats do instead.

Under the 2014 rules, Great Weapon Master and Sharpshooter let you take −5 to an attack roll for +10 damage. Used at the right moment, that trade is one of the biggest damage boosts in the game; used at the wrong moment, it just makes you miss. The 2024 rules redesigned both feats and removed the trade entirely. This guide gives a simple rule for the 2014 versions and explains what the 2024 versions do instead.

The trade in numbers

Taking −5 to hit lowers your hit chance by 25 percentage points. Adding +10 damage raises the damage of every hit. Whether that is worth it depends on how often you hit to begin with and how much damage you already do. If p is your normal chance to hit and D your average damage per hit:

Normal: p × D · Power attack: (p − 0.25) × (D + 10)

Setting the two equal gives a clean rule of thumb:

Use −5/+10 when your normal chance to hit is above (D + 10) ÷ 40

  • Greatsword with +4 Strength (2d6 + 4, average 11): use it when your normal hit chance is above 52.5%.
  • Longbow with +4 Dexterity (1d8 + 4, average 8.5): use it above 46%.
  • Heavy crossbow with +5 (1d10 + 5, average 10.5): above 51%.

In plain terms: if you need a 10 or less on the die to hit normally, take the penalty. At 11 it is roughly even. If you need 12 or more, don’t, unless something else is helping.

A worked example

A level 5 fighter with 18 Strength attacks with a greatsword at +7 to hit, average 11 damage per hit, and 2d6 (7) more on a critical hit. Damage per attack against different Armor Classes:

Target ACNormal−5/+10Normal, advantage−5/+10, advantage
138.610.8511.016.4
157.58.7510.314.1
176.46.659.511.4
185.855.68.99.9
204.753.57.76.5

Against the AC 13–15 enemies that make up most early fights, power attacking adds roughly 15–25% to your damage. Around AC 17–18 it breaks even. Against AC 20 it costs you damage.

Advantage changes everything

Look at the advantage columns. With advantage, power attacking stays better all the way up to AC 18 or 19. Advantage protects you from the main downside of the trade, missing, so it pairs perfectly with it. That is why the classic 2014 builds combine Great Weapon Master with a barbarian’s Reckless Attack, a paladin’s Vow of Enmity or allies who knock enemies prone, and Sharpshooter with the Archery fighting style (+2 to hit) or Bless.

The flip side: if you have disadvantage, almost never power attack.

Using it at the table

  1. Work out your break-even hit chance once, with the formula above or the calculator.
  2. When you don’t know the target’s AC, make your first attack normally and use the result to estimate it.
  3. Switch on the −5/+10 whenever you have advantage, Bless or a similar bonus.
  4. Switch it off against heavily armored foes or when you have disadvantage.

The other halves of these feats matter too. Great Weapon Master’s bonus-action attack after a critical hit or a kill, and Sharpshooter’s ability to ignore cover and shoot at long range without disadvantage, are useful in every fight, whatever the target’s AC.

What the 2024 versions do

The 2024 rules dropped the −5/+10 trade from both feats:

  • Great Weapon Master (2024) raises Strength by 1. When you hit with a Heavy weapon as part of the Attack action on your turn, you add extra damage equal to your proficiency bonus, with no penalty to hit. You can still make a bonus-action attack after a critical hit or after reducing a creature to 0 hit points.
  • Sharpshooter (2024) raises Dexterity by 1, lets your ranged attacks ignore half and three-quarters cover, removes the disadvantage for shooting while an enemy is next to you, and removes the disadvantage at long range. It no longer adds damage.

For Great Weapon Master the maths becomes simple: the extra damage is always on, so there is no decision to make. A level 5 fighter adds +3 to each hit; with two attacks at 65% that is about 3.9 more damage per round, rising as proficiency grows. Sharpshooter becomes a utility feat that keeps archers effective in awkward positions rather than a damage feat.

The hit chance and DPR calculator has a power attack switch for the 2014 rules and shows both results side by side, so you can check any weapon and target in seconds.

Sources: System Reference Document 5.1 and 5.2 (CC-BY-4.0) and the fifth edition core rules. Worked examples are our own. First published 7 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us and we will correct it. Read how we write and check our guides in our editorial policy.