Dungeon Mastering

Initiative and Surprise: How Turn Order Works in 2014 and 2024

How initiative is rolled, how ties and groups work, how surprise changed in the 2024 rules, and how much a good initiative bonus is really worth.

Initiative decides who acts first, and in a game where a single spell can end a fight, going first matters. The basic rule hasn’t changed between editions, but the 2024 rules handle surprise very differently. This guide covers how initiative works, how ties and groups are handled, what changed with surprise, and how much a good initiative bonus is actually worth.

The initiative roll

When combat starts, every participant rolls initiative: a Dexterity check, so d20 + Dexterity modifier + any bonuses that apply to initiative. The Dungeon Master ranks everyone from highest to lowest, and that order repeats every round until the fight ends. Creatures that join later roll when they arrive and slot into the order.

Initiative isn’t an attack roll, so a natural 20 isn’t special and a natural 1 isn’t a failure; they are just high and low numbers.

Ties and groups

  • Ties between monsters are settled by the DM, and ties between characters by the players. When a monster and a character tie, the DM decides. A common shortcut is to let the higher Dexterity go first.
  • Groups: the DM can roll once for a group of identical creatures, such as six wolves, so they all act on the same count. It saves time and makes the order easier to track, but it also means the whole group acts at once, which concentrates their damage. For a dangerous group, consider splitting it into two smaller groups.

Surprise: the big 2024 change

2014 rules: the DM decides whether anyone is surprised, usually by comparing the ambushers’ Dexterity (Stealth) checks with the defenders’ passive Wisdom (Perception). Surprised creatures still roll initiative, but on their first turn they can’t move or take an action, and they can’t take reactions until that turn ends. In practice, a successful ambush gives the attackers a free round.

2024 rules: a surprised creature rolls initiative with disadvantage. That is the whole effect. It acts normally on its turn, just probably later. Ambushes are still strong, but they no longer remove a character from the first round entirely.

The difference is easiest to see with numbers. With the 2014 rule, a surprised wizard who rolls high still loses their first turn. With the 2024 rule, the same wizard’s average roll drops from 10.5 to about 7.2, but they still get to act, and about a third of the time they will still act before an enemy with the same bonus.

How much is an initiative bonus worth?

Because both sides roll a d20, a bonus over your opponent matters less than it looks. The chance of acting before one enemy, by how much your initiative bonus exceeds theirs (ties split evenly):

Your bonus minus theirsChance you go first
050%
+155%
+260%
+364%
+572%
+779%
+1088%

Against a group it matters more. If four goblins each have +2 initiative, a character with +2 acts before all of them only about 18% of the time. With +5 that rises to about 33%, and with +7 to about 43%. For a controller whose first spell can decide the fight, that is a big difference.

Ways to improve initiative

Source2014 rules2024 rules
DexterityAdds its modifierAdds its modifier
Alert feat+5, and you can’t be surprisedAdds your proficiency bonus, and you can swap initiative with a willing ally
Advantage on initiativeFrom features such as Feral InstinctFrom features such as Feral Instinct; the 2024 Alert swap also helps the whole party
Jack of All Trades (Bard)Adds half your proficiency bonusDoesn’t apply: it now covers only skill checks

Running initiative smoothly

  1. Have players roll as soon as you describe the threat, while you roll for the monsters.
  2. Read the order out once and keep it visible: on a whiteboard, a card stack or the initiative tracker.
  3. Tell the next player they are “on deck” so they can plan.
  4. Group identical monsters unless the fight is meant to be deadly.
  5. When the last creature in the order has acted, say the round number aloud. It helps everyone track spell durations.

To compare two initiative bonuses directly, or to see the effect of advantage, use the dice probability calculator.

Sources: System Reference Document 5.1 and 5.2 (CC-BY-4.0) and the fifth edition core rules. Worked examples are our own. First published 7 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us and we will correct it. Read how we write and check our guides in our editorial policy.

More for your table

From our sister site Best DnD Generators, free generators for players and DMs: